Files
ElyOffice/tasks/reviews/S-05-r1.md
T

1.0 KiB
Raw Blame History

FAIL

apps/ely-show/src/remarks.rs:229 — Unscrollable error rows can still hide every readable comment (SHOW-08). The danger messages occupy the outer column above the sidebar, while scrolling belongs exclusively to the sidebar below them. Reproduction: render the actual remarks pane at 280×600 with one comment dated 2025-03-01 and twelve comments dated 0-00-00. Native macOS rendering shows only errors; the readable comment and later errors lie below the viewport. Three downward scroll gestures at different heights leave the screenshot pixel-identical, preventing selection, editing and navigation to the readable comment. A layout probe also fails with eight bad dates, placing the readable row at y=740 in a 600-high pane. The supplied unit test passes because it checks only threads(). Put the errors into a scrollable layout that preserves access to readable comments, and cover multiple invalid timestamps with a rendered-pane scrolling regression test. Evidence: /tmp/ely-s05-r1-layout.log and /tmp/ely-s05-r1-native.log.