Files
ElyOffice/tasks/reviews/C01.1-r2.md
T

1.2 KiB

PASS

Checks run: cargo check --workspace (clean), cargo clippy --workspace --all-targets (clean), cargo fmt --check (clean), cargo test --workspace (3 passed), tests/scripts/apps-start.sh (8 of 8 open a window, draw, and quit), tests/scripts/agents_md.py (117 names are public). Every file is under 500 lines, and every comment fits on one line.

The five round-1 defects:

  1. Fixed. Logging still uses log + env_logger. agents.md rule 4 now says log, matching gpui. Neither the code nor the rules mention tracing anywhere.
  2. Fixed. crates/ely-ui/src/shell.rs:20 returns the FocusScope root directly. The wrapper and debug_selector are gone.
  3. Fixed. The repeated h1 app name is removed. The window shows only the themed content area.
  4. Fixed. The [workspace.lints.rust] check-cfg entry is removed from Cargo.toml.
  5. Fixed. tests/scripts/apps-start.sh:17 sets XDG_DATA_HOME to a path inside the temp dir.

The changed code (Cargo.toml, agents.md, crates/ely-ui/src/run.rs, crates/ely-ui/src/shell.rs, tests/scripts/apps-start.sh) has no new defects. Showing a reason when the graphics backend fails to start (PRD §4.1) belongs to C01.2, so it is out of scope here.