Sweep every first-party crate source (1956 .rs files) to the project comment
guidelines: delete redundant restatements, decorative banners, change
narration, and end-of-line comments; keep and tighten the crucial ones
(invariants, bug rationale, SAFETY blocks, ported-source attribution).
No functional code changed. Every edit is proven comment-only against the
prior tree by a comment-stripping lexer (string/char/raw-string aware) plus a
separate doctest-fence check. Where removing a comment made rustfmt or clippy
want to re-lay-out adjacent code, the minimal triggering comment is restored so
code tokens stay byte-identical.
Gates green: cargo fmt --all --check (0 diffs), cargo check and cargo clippy
--workspace --all-targets (0 warnings).
Adds scripts/check_codegen_comment_guidelines.py — the enforcement gate for
these guidelines (flags banners, end-of-line comments, change narration, and
commented-out code).
Root cause of 'model+effort switch works on Mac, not on Windows': the
switch APPLIES in-session (the dispatch/apply chain is platform-identical,
verified adversarially) but its persistence never sticks on Windows.
Every tmp+rename atomic write except auth/storage.rs committed with a
bare fs::rename, and Windows MoveFileExW(REPLACE_EXISTING) fails with a
sharing violation whenever AV/search-indexer/cloud-sync transiently holds
the destination open. Consequences: [models].default never persisted
(next launch = original model), the session summary's current model never
persisted (resume = original model), and the models cache went silently
stale (all its write errors were swallowed).
- New kigi_shell_base::util::fs::replace_file — THE commit step for
tmp+rename: plain rename on Unix; on Windows delete-first + two short
backoffs (the pattern auth/storage.rs shipped first), tmp cleaned on
failure, error always returned. Windows branch type-checked against
x86_64-pc-windows-msvc.
- Adopted at every replace site: config.toml (save_config /
atomic_write_string / mcp saves), models cache (plus unique tmp
suffixes and tracing::warn on failure — writes were fully silent),
session storage (summary/current-model, jsonl, plan/signals/
announcement/goal/graph state), auth.json, active-sessions registry,
prompt history, claude/kimi import, campaigns state, goal artifacts.
Directory-move renames (worktree pool, corrupt-file backups) keep
plain rename — their destinations don't pre-exist.
Verified: kigi-shell + kigi-shell-base 5318 tests green, clippy clean,
msvc-target check of the new cfg(windows) code clean.
The 11th registry row and the first THIRD-PARTY wire_serves_metadata=true
provider: id "openrouter", OPENROUTER_API_KEY > auth.json "openrouter"
scope, https://openrouter.ai/api/v1 (note /api/v1) with
KIGI_OPENROUTER_BASE_URL override, Bearer, OpenAI listing +
ChatCompletions + Passthrough.
OpenRouter's public /models serves context_length for every model
(verified live: 340/340), so it needs NO enrichment: models_dev_id=None,
wire_serves_metadata=true, restrict_to_enriched=false. An OpenRouter-only
user makes zero models.dev calls; context comes straight from the listing.
Slashed ids (anthropic/claude-opus-4.8) round-trip through the managed key
via the first-slash split; the native id rides the wire. The e2e pins all
of this with the models.dev refresh disabled.
Review-confirmed defect fixed (and independently re-verified with live
curls): OpenRouter's /models is PUBLIC — GET /models returns 200 for ANY
key — so login key-validation would false-accept a bad key, deferring the
failure to the first chat 401. New spec field key_validation_path lets a
public-listing platform validate against an auth-requiring endpoint;
OpenRouter uses /key (401s for bad keys). Reusable for Vercel (also
public). Tests pin the /key validation and no regression to the default
/models path.
Gate caught a fixture regression: the kimi_import test used openrouter.ai
to represent a CUSTOM provider, which now correctly dedupes to the builtin
OpenRouter — moved the fixture to a reserved llm.example.test host that no
future platform can shadow.
The 4th registry row: id "openai", OPENAI_API_KEY env > auth.json
"openai" scope (login picker/paste/validation all registry-generic —
zero TUI changes needed, pinned by the picker test), base
https://api.openai.com/v1 with KIGI_OPENAI_BASE_URL override, Responses
dialect via the new PlatformWireApi spec field, enrichment-backed
metadata (wire_serves_metadata=false).
OpenAI's GET /v1/models returns bare ids and is polluted with
tts/whisper/embeddings entries: the listing is restricted to
enrichment-known TOOL-CALLING models (review caught that membership
alone admitted models.dev-known embeddings models, which would 400 on
every agentic request; dropped ids are debug-logged for launch-day
diagnosability). Context windows, effort menus, display names, and
thinking capability come from the enrichment pipeline — wiremock e2e
pins the full contract: polluted live listing + models.dev →
one Responses-backed chat model with a 400k documented context window.
Responses max-effort wiring (closes the P0c-1 debt): canonical effort
rides a CreateResponseWrapper sidecar and patch_reasoning_effort writes
it onto the serialized body at both send sites (all seven levels pinned,
xhigh/max distinct, summary preserved); normalize_effort_echo drops
echoes async-openai's typed enum cannot represent at both the non-stream
and SSE parse seams; the dead typed to_responses_api converter is
deleted. Kimi/moonshot stay byte-identical (ChatCompletions untouched,
wire_api maps to the same default; kimi wire tests green).
kimi-import now recognizes ANY registry platform host as built-in
(was hardcoded moonshot), covering openai and future rows.
New `kigi import-kimi` (with --dry-run) plus a one-time welcome-screen
hint when ~/.kimi/config.toml is present and unimported.
- Sources: ~/.kimi/config.toml (default_model, [models.*], [providers.*])
and ~/.kimi/mcp.json ({"mcpServers": ...} — parsed by the existing
McpConfig machinery). Shapes ported from kimi-cli 1.49.0 config.py with
citations.
- Strictly read-only over ~/.kimi: plain reads only; the test suite pins
byte-identical contents AND unchanged mtimes across scan+apply. Keyring
credentials are never imported; KIMI_SHARE_DIR / any KIMI_* env var is
never consulted (official dir hardcoded to ~/.kimi).
- Mapping: MCP servers merge into kigi [mcp_servers.*] without clobbering
existing names; models on non-built-in providers become kigi [model.*]
custom entries (base_url + api_key + context_window); providers that
duplicate kigi's built-in Kimi/Moonshot platforms are skipped with a
note; default_model maps to the imported alias or the managed catalog
key and never overwrites an existing default.
- One-time marker ~/.kigi/kimi_import_done (claude-import convention);
the startup hint and re-runs no-op once set. api_key values flow only
into the user's own config.toml and are redacted in every summary.
Verified end-to-end with the real binary in a sandboxed home: dry-run,
apply, `kigi mcp list` shows both imported servers, second run no-ops,
~/.kimi mtimes unchanged. 8 unit tests + CLI parse test.
ZacharyZhang-NY