Judge the CLI teardown by what is left, and match flags as definitions

Two review follow-ups. The probe counted any mention of --tui/--query in
the help as support -- Hermes already writes "With --tui:" into --dev's
description, so a release that dropped the option while keeping the
prose would still read as ready. A flag now counts only when followed by
a shape argparse prints after a definition: the usage bracket, the gap
before same-line help text, an uppercase metavar, or the line end. Not
probed by parsing a real invocation on purpose -- a release that ignores
unknown arguments would turn the probe into a live session.

And the teardown trusted its commands: a stub rm that failed aborted
Remove Hermes under set -e before any ~/.hermes handling, while mise
failures vanished into || true. --remove now attempts every step, then
judges by what is left -- the marked stub still present, or mise still
resolving the tool -- and Remove Hermes tolerates the failure until the
runtime is handled, then carries it in its exit code.

Findings from the same codex review at xhigh, verified and proven by
mutation before landing.

Co-Authored-By: Codex <noreply@openai.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
committed 2026-09-02 01:01:13 -05:00
1 parent c462aad9ee
commit 46cfc4ada5
4 files changed
+81 -10

No files matched your search

+34 -1
View File
@@ -430,12 +430,19 @@ pass "--remove is idempotent when no Hermes CLI is present"
printf '%s\n' "#!/bin/bash" "$stub_marker" >"$remove_home/.local/bin/hermes"
chmod +x "$remove_home/.local/bin/hermes"
: >"$mise_log"
OMARCHY_TEST_MISE_WHERE_OK=1 run_remove || fail "--remove succeeds tearing down an owned CLI"
run_remove || fail "--remove succeeds tearing down an owned CLI"
tr '\0' '\n' <"$mise_log" | grep -q '^rm$' || fail "--remove drops the mise tool from config"
tr '\0' '\n' <"$mise_log" | grep -q '^uninstall$' || fail "--remove uninstalls the mise tool"
[[ ! -e $remove_home/.local/bin/hermes ]] || fail "--remove takes the stub it owns"
pass "--remove tears down the mise CLI and the stub this installer owns"
# When mise still resolves the tool after the teardown, the environment
# survived whatever uninstall claimed, and --remove has to say so.
printf '%s\n' "#!/bin/bash" "$stub_marker" >"$remove_home/.local/bin/hermes"
chmod +x "$remove_home/.local/bin/hermes"
OMARCHY_TEST_MISE_WHERE_OK=1 run_remove && fail "--remove claims success while mise still resolves the tool"
pass "--remove fails when the mise environment survives the teardown"
foreign_remove_body="#!/bin/bash
exec /usr/local/bin/my-own-hermes \"\$@\""
printf '%s\n' "$foreign_remove_body" >"$remove_home/.local/bin/hermes"
@@ -450,6 +457,16 @@ tr '\0' '\n' <"$mise_log" | grep -Eq '^(rm|uninstall)$' &&
fail "--remove never removes a mise environment it cannot prove is Omarchy's"
pass "--remove leaves a Hermes the user installed themselves"
# Judged by what is left, not by what rm claimed: a stub that survives the
# teardown is a CLI still installed, and --remove has to say so.
printf '%s\n' "#!/bin/bash" "$stub_marker" >"$remove_home/.local/bin/hermes"
chmod +x "$remove_home/.local/bin/hermes"
chmod 555 "$remove_home/.local/bin"
run_remove && fail "--remove claims success while the stub survives"
chmod 755 "$remove_home/.local/bin"
rm -f "$remove_home/.local/bin/hermes"
pass "--remove fails when the stub cannot be removed"
# The app's marker says its install once landed, not that it is still there. A
# wrapper whose runtime has since gone answers for nothing, so readiness runs
# the command, exactly as it does for a hermes the user installed themselves.
@@ -541,3 +558,19 @@ SH
chmod +x "$ready_home/.hermes/hermes-agent/venv/bin/hermes"
run_ready_check && fail "--check accepts flags that extend --tui/--query with an underscore"
pass "an underscore continuation is not the bare flag"
# A flag mentioned in another option's help text is not that option. Hermes
# already writes "With --tui:" into --dev's description, so prose has to stay
# prose even when both names appear in it.
cat >"$ready_home/.hermes/hermes-agent/venv/bin/hermes" <<'SH'
#!/bin/bash
if [[ ${1:-} == "chat" && ${2:-} == "--help" ]]; then
echo " --dev With --tui: run sources via tsx"
echo " --log FILE Where --query output lands"
else
echo "hermes-agent 0.0.0-test"
fi
SH
chmod +x "$ready_home/.hermes/hermes-agent/venv/bin/hermes"
run_ready_check && fail "--check accepts flags that appear only in option descriptions"
pass "a flag mentioned in prose is not a defined option"